Skip Navigation Website Accessibility
We have a new location!   We are now located inside The Heritage Mall on Van Buren Street in Nashville, IN! 


Wishful Thinking

The Heritage Mall, 41 S Van Buren St, Nashville, IN 47448  |  (812) 988-7009


We have a new location! 

Our new home is in The Heritage Mall,
41 S Van Buren Street, Nashville, IN.

OPEN:  Every Day
10am - 5pm


You can also contact us by email:

Our online store is open 24/7 and filled with tempting treats for paper crafters!











Welcome! We're Glad You're Here!

Directions to our new location at the Heritage Mall, 41 S Van Buren Street, Nashville, IN: From our old shop (the one that burned), walk about 1.5 blocks north on Old School Way.  The back entrance to the Heritage Mall will be on your left (it's set back from the road a bit).  If you recall our original location on Old School Way, the Heritage Mall is right across the street.  

The front entrance to the Heritage Mall is on Van Buren Street, near the traffic light on Main Street & Van Buren.  Nearby establishments include: Our Sandwich Place, The Ordinary,  Brown County Art Guild, The Hob Knob and Moonshine Leather.  

Inside the Heritage Mall is The Heritage Candy Shop (mmm!), Hoosier Spice Company, Hart Beauty Studio, The Wondering Conjurer Shop of Mysteries, Redefined Clothesline, a handmade jewelry shop, Juls, and Head Over Heels. Oh, and now Wishful Thinking!

We continue to host our ATC swap!  Anyone can participate in this FREE activity!  Click on the ATC page to learn more!

Special Orders

We are always looking for unusual stamps, supplies and gifts. We can special order those hard-to-find items for you.

Birthday Discount

Come into Wishful Thinking on your birthday (or the day before or after) and receive the discount of your age on one regularly priced item.

Contact Us

  • The Heritage Mall, 41 S Van Buren St
    Nashville, IN 47448

    Phone:  812-988-7009
  • Email:

Wishful Thinking

Located in the heart of scenic Nashville, Indiana, Wishful Thinking offers high quality scrapbooking and stamping supplies you are not likely to find in chain stores or at other so-called craft stores. We welcome you to shop with us online!  We'd love to see you in person, too, so you can see our entire product selection.  Any questions or need more info on a product? Call us at the shop and we'll be happy to help!